The “Smelly Goat” Principle: Why Agencies Must Push Back for Client Success

Marcus Aurelius, the Stoic emperor, offers timeless wisdom that resonates even in today’s business landscape. One of his lesser-known but profoundly insightful passage is often paraphrased as the “smelly goat” analogy, which goes:

‍

“Just as the unpleasant smell of a goat or the odor of a sweaty horse is inseparable from the animal, so are falsehood and arrogance inseparable from some people.”

‍

In the context of client-agency relationships, it serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of honesty and assertiveness.  In Marcus Aurelius’s analogy, the “smelly goat” represents inherent flaws that go unaddressed unless someone points them out. If the agency remains silent, the “smell” persists, and the company continues down an unproductive path. By courageously pointing out the “smell,” the agency fulfills its role as a strategic partner.

‍

The Trap of Complacency in Client Relationships

Businesses often seek agencies because they lack the resources or expertise to achieve their goals. They recognize their limitations and look to external partners for guidance. However, the dynamic can become counterproductive when agencies hesitate to push back against clients’ misguided decisions.

• ‍Client’s Familiarity Bias: Companies know their products and customers intimately but may be blind to the flaws that led them to seek help in the first place.‍
• Agency’s Fear of Conflict: Agencies might avoid challenging clients to maintain harmony, fearing that pushback could jeopardize the relationship.

This delicate balance can lead to agencies becoming mere implementation partners—executing tasks without contributing strategic value. They become like the goat unaware of its own smell, unable to recognize and rectify underlying issues.

‍

Embracing the Role of the Strategic Partner

Agencies must strive to be more than just task executors; they should act as strategic partners who guide clients toward success. This involves:

• ‍Honest Communication: Openly discussing potential pitfalls in clients’ strategies.‍
• Expert Guidance: Leveraging industry expertise to offer alternative solutions.‍
• Constructive Pushback: Respectfully challenging clients when necessary to prevent costly mistakes.

‍

The Importance of Pushback

Pushing back isn’t about being combative; it’s about adding value. When agencies provide candid feedback, they help clients avoid repeating past mistakes and pave the way for innovation.

• ‍Preventing Echo Chambers: Without external perspectives, businesses may reinforce ineffective strategies.‍
• Driving Growth: Challenging the status quo can lead to breakthrough ideas and competitive advantages.‍
• Building Trust: Honest interactions strengthen the client-agency relationship over time.

‍Choosing the Right Agency: A Mutual Responsibility

For businesses, selecting an agency isn’t just about capabilities; it’s about finding a partner willing to engage in meaningful dialogue.

What to Look For in an Agency

• ‍‍Proactivity: Agencies that take the initiative to understand your business deeply.‍
• Transparency: Willingness to share honest observations, even if they are uncomfortable.‍
• Expertise: A track record of strategic thinking and successful outcomes.‍
• Collaborative Spirit: An approach that values partnership over mere service provision.

For Agencies: Cultivating the Courage to Push Back

Agencies must develop the confidence to voice concerns and offer alternative perspectives.

• Establish Clear Communication Channels: Set expectations early about the nature of the partnership.
• ‍Educate the Client: Provide data and insights to support your recommendations.
• ‍Practice Empathy: Understand the client’s perspective to frame your pushback constructively.

The Consequences of Not Pushing Back

When agencies fail to assert their expertise:

• Suboptimal Results: Projects may not achieve desired outcomes, reflecting poorly on both parties.
• ‍Erosion of Trust: Clients may lose confidence in the agency’s ability to lead.
• ‍Missed Opportunities: The potential for innovation and growth diminishes.

Embracing the “Smelly Goat” Principle

Marcus Aurelius’s metaphor serves as a powerful reminder that ignoring inherent issues doesn’t make them disappear. Agencies have a responsibility to identify and address the “smelly goats” in their clients’ strategies. By pushing back respectfully and constructively, agencies transition from mere implementers to valuable strategic partners. This not only leads to better outcomes but also fosters stronger, more resilient relationships.

In the end, the courage to speak up defines the true value of an agency. It’s about ensuring that both the agency and the client aren’t just moving forward but moving forward on the right path.

Are you seeking an agency that won’t shy away from telling you what you need to hear? One that will partner with you strategically rather than just executing tasks? Let’s start a conversation about how we can work together to achieve your goals.